Germany is rewriting the rules for its spies. The Bundestag on Friday approved a major overhaul of the law governing the country's intelligence services, giving the foreign intelligence agency, the BND, and the domestic service, the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV), new powers to disrupt threats instead of just observing them. The vote was 309 in favour, 190 against and 71 abstentions, according to the BBC; Al Jazeera reported the tally as 308 votes to 190 with 71 abstentions. The governing Christian Democrats and Social Democrats backed the reform, while the far-right Alternative for Germany and the Left Party opposed it. Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt, who championed the bill, called it a "reform of the century", saying it is needed because of mounting threats from foreign powers.
The changes are significant for a country whose intelligence tradition has been shaped by history. For historical reasons, German intelligence has mainly focused on gathering information rather than acting on it, the BBC notes. Under the new law, the BND will be able to carry out covert operations abroad, including sabotage, which could mean paralysing the servers of state-sponsored hacker groups, disrupting disinformation networks or even interfering with weapons supply chains. The BfV will no longer be limited to collecting information: for the first time it will be allowed to take protective action against property and IT systems when specific threats are identified, including dismantling or breaking explosives or weapons, diverting or blocking data flows during cyber-attacks, deleting or falsifying data stored for malicious purposes, and planting false information on those involved. Under certain conditions, BfV agents will also be permitted to enter homes covertly, though each such measure must be authorised in advance. The law also widens digital surveillance powers, including monitoring encrypted communications, online searches, AI-supported data analysis and biometric image matching on the internet.
The government's argument is that the old system left a gap. Intelligence agencies could often identify a threat but lacked the authority to intervene, even when no other agency was responsible or able to act, Al Jazeera reported. Mr Dobrindt said Germany is "the target of hybrid threats" and a "theatre of operations for terrorism, extremism and foreign powers," and that the changes put German agencies on an equal footing with their European partners. Experts who spoke to the Bundestag during earlier debates said Berlin's capabilities "lack modern intervention powers" compared with Western counterparts. The reform, argued Florian Bigge of the Koerber-Stiftung think tank, is a direct result of the "Zeitenwende," the epochal change in German foreign policy since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. He said the BND had publicly sought expanded powers since 2024, and that "Russia is the main trigger: sabotage, cyberattacks and drones," along with fears of US unpredictability and reduced US intelligence sharing.
The timing underlines that argument. In August, German authorities found a drone carrying an explosive device at Leipzig-Halle airport near cargo planes belonging to the Ukrainian firm Antonov Airlines; the bomb failed to explode because its detonator was apparently faulty, the BBC reported. Berlin formally accused Russia of attempting the attack, with Mr Dobrindt saying the intelligence community had determined that the drone was consistent with Russian technology. Russia denied involvement, but Germany closed the Russian consulate general in Bonn and the Russian House cultural centre in Berlin, and Moscow responded by closing a German consulate in St Petersburg and the Goethe-Institut. The government says the reform is needed because of increased espionage from Russia, China and Iran.
The critics see a different risk. Clara Bünger, the Left Party's security spokeswoman, told public broadcaster ARD that the law was "a monster… summoning ghosts that we will probably never be able to get rid of," and said the separation between the police and the secret service was "being eroded", a principle she said was a lesson learned from the Nazi era. "This means the secret service is being granted executive powers and will not only be allowed to act pre-emptively, but will also be granted police powers," she said. The Left argued in a parliamentary motion that key provisions fail to meet constitutional standards for intrusive surveillance and warned that the powers would effectively create a German secret police, a prospect with particular resonance for those who lived under the Stasi, East Germany's secret police from 1950 to 1990. Mr Dobrindt has dismissed this, calling it "madness" to think the law amounts to a new secret police.
The coalition has its own answer. Sonja Eichwede of the centre-left Social Democrats, which governs alongside the Christian Democrats, said the reforms would make a significant contribution to ensuring that the country's democracy is "robust and resilient." Supporters point out that the new powers are bound by conditions, that covert entry into homes needs prior authorisation, and that action against threats is limited to cases where specific dangers have been identified. The political argument is likely to continue. The Left, which won the Berlin city-state election in September with 25.7% of the vote, according to Al Jazeera, is in a strong position to keep the issue alive, and Mr Bigge said that while criticism so far has come from lawmakers and civil liberties groups, "a broader public debate may still come."
Why does it matter? The reform changes Germany's security model at the moment when its neighbours and allies are also rethinking theirs. A state that has long separated information gathering from action is now giving its agencies tools to hack, disrupt and, in some cases, sabotage hostile operations, and it is doing so against the background of Russian pressure and uncertainty about the United States. If the powers work as the government intends, they could prevent attacks of the kind seen at Leipzig-Halle. If they are misused, or if oversight proves inadequate, they could undermine the trust that postwar Germany built on the strict limits placed on its intelligence services.
The real test will come in how the law is applied. Authorisation procedures, parliamentary oversight and judicial review will decide whether the new powers are exercised proportionately, and the first operations carried out under the law, once they become public, will shape the debate. For now, Germany has chosen to give its spies the ability to act, and its lawmakers and courts will have to decide how far that ability should extend.
