England produced one of the finest performances of Thomas Tuchel's reign on Sunday night, beating the world champions Spain 3-2 in Madrid to end their 43-match unbeaten run and finish top of their Nations League group, although only after a frantic final half hour in which they were reduced to ten men. The match was played at the Metropolitano, where Spain's players had paraded the World Cup trophy in front of England's team as the sides lined up. What followed, in the BBC's words, reduced Spain's supporters to stunned silence and their players to a shell-shocked shambles. England went 3-0 up inside an hour with a suffocating high press, and then had to survive a spell of pressure that tested the squad's resilience and, for many watching, brought back uncomfortable memories of this summer's World Cup.

The goals told the story of England's early dominance. Harry Kane gave them the lead from the penalty spot just before half-time after Spain's Pau Cubarsi fouled him in the box, following a pass from Elliot Anderson and a brief VAR check on an earlier challenge on Marc Cucurella. Eight minutes after the restart Ezri Konsa doubled the lead with a powerful downward header from a Declan Rice corner, and four minutes later Ben White, Konsa's Arsenal team-mate, finished a superb move for the third. Spain's goalkeeper Unai Simon had earlier made a brilliant reaction save to claw away a close-range effort from Jude Bellingham, who was the outstanding player on the pitch according to the BBC's report. Kane's goal was his 93rd for England, and the BBC called the first 65 minutes simply breathtaking, with England running all over a team that has carried all before it.

Then the match turned. After 65 minutes Jarell Quansah was dispossessed in his own half and Anderson was shown a straight red card for denying a goalscoring opportunity by putting his arm on Lamine Yamal as he raced into the area. Mikel Oyarzabal converted the penalty, and with 15 minutes left Yamal set up substitute Nico Williams, whose first-time finish, swept in off the post, made it 3-2. England had to survive 29 nervous minutes, including added time. Goalkeeper James Trafford made six saves, four of them in the final 12 minutes with the score at 3-2, according to BBC Sport, including a double save to deny Fermin Lopez and Yamal in injury time. The result left both sides on 15 points in the group, with England finishing top on goal difference.

Advertisement

The case for calling this a landmark result is strong. Spain are the reigning world champions and European champions, and the BBC noted that both titles are currently in their possession. Setting aside their penalty shootout defeat by Portugal in the 2025 Nations Cup final, the defeat ended a 43-game unbeaten run. Al Jazeera described it as Spain's first defeat since March 2024. England had also been under pressure after the way their World Cup campaign ended, and Tuchel called the occasion "proof of concept at the highest level". Before the game he had told reporters that England were "up for something spectacular". Afterwards he said: "What a performance we put out for 65 minutes to be deservedly 3-0 up", adding that "the red card and the penalty changed the momentum" but that "that is the statement – and that is the significance of this victory." He went on to praise the deep build-up, the high press, the counter-attack and the defending, saying everything that needed to be done had been done together.

The case for caution rests on how close it came to slipping away, and on what the World Cup taught England. In the semi-final in Atlanta, England led Argentina 1-0 through Anthony Gordon in the 55th minute and still had all their players, but Lionel Messi set up Enzo Fernandez and Lautaro Martinez scored late as England sat back. In the last 16, with England 2-1 up against Mexico at the Azteca after Quansah was sent off, Tuchel brought on three defenders for a defender, a midfielder and a forward, and England won 3-2, with Dan Burn's cameo described as the stuff of legend. Nine days later, with England 1-0 up against Argentina, he made the same set of changes, and the first of them, Konsa for Gordon, came in the 72nd minute. The BBC's analysis argued that this time England faced even more of a siege: in the final 30 minutes they faced 19 shots from Spain, seven of them on target, with an expected goals total of 2.53, compared with 10 shots, four on target and an xG of 1.41 against Argentina in the same period.

What was different, according to the same analysis, was Tuchel's approach to substitutions and the players' reaction. He was not quick with defensive changes: Myles Lewis-Skelly came on for Kane after 78 minutes, 15 minutes after Anderson's red card, and five minutes later he brought on two more players, one of whom was the striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin. Burn replaced fellow defender White only in the 89th minute. Tuchel explained that Kane had played 78 minutes and Bellingham 83 and that "we needed fresh energy", adding that he felt "free enough" to make any substitution he thought necessary. After Spain pulled one back, England's players also had a huddle, and the former England defender Matt Upson said on BBC Radio 5 Live that he loved the fact that the team went into a huddle while the manager stepped back to see the players' reaction. White said the message was to "stay calm" and manage the situation. Tuchel compared the finish to the Mexico game, saying that for half an hour "it was Mexico reloaded and it felt like we were back in the Azteca".

The wider context is a team trying to show it has learned from this summer. England had been criticised for blowing a 2-1 half-time lead at Wembley in their first Nations League meeting with Spain, when, according to the BBC, they faced only five shots in the final 30 minutes but still could not hold on. On Thursday they had beaten Croatia 2-1, completing 557 passes with 89% accuracy, and Tuchel said the group stage as a whole showed the steps the team had taken since the World Cup. He said the squad wanted to get better at building deep, defending in a low block and imposing its identity against every opponent. The BBC's verdict was that the performance showed England could match the best and then beat them, while cautioning that the Nations League is competitive but cannot be compared with a World Cup or a European Championship, and that England must repeat it when the pressure and expectation are at their highest.

Individual performances reinforced the sense of a team coming together. The BBC singled out Bellingham as "the player with everything", praised Kane for reaching 93 international goals, and said White was making a strong claim for the right-back berth with a goal and crucial challenges in the closing stages. It also credited Tuchel for getting his big calls right, particularly in choosing Trafford in goal. Anderson's red card will be a talking point, though the BBC pointed to Quansah's initial loss of possession as the main culprit, and Tuchel said the team "know very, very well what they put out there". Upson went further, arguing that the trauma of the sending off might even have been positive because it gave the team a chance to come together and cope with an incredibly difficult situation.

For England, the result is as much about belief as about points. They have beaten the world champions away from home with ten men for the last half hour, finished top of a group that included the same opponents, and answered at least some of the questions about Tuchel's tactical courage. For Spain, it is a rare reminder that a long unbeaten run can end in a single evening, and that a 3-0 deficit, even when partly recovered, is hard to escape. The next tests will come in competitions where, as the BBC pointed out, England must do it again under the highest pressure and expectation. But on a night in Madrid when they were 3-0 up against the best team in the world, England showed what they can do when they play without fear.