When a letter from the army lands in your mailbox at eighteen, it tends to focus the mind. For Phil Werring, a high school student in Münster, western Germany, that letter was the beginning of something bigger than a form. Last month he received a military registration form from the Bundeswehr, Germany’s armed forces, and what he felt, he told Al Jazeera, was fear and anger.

On Friday, November 20, he and thousands of other young Germans are expected to join nationwide rallies against conscription and what they see as growing militarization.

The letter that started it

Werring first ignored the form. Two weeks later, he received a second letter warning of a 250 euro ($275) fine if he did not answer. He logged in through a QR code and worked through the questionnaire.

Advertisement

“The mandatory questions included ones on whether you have any diseases, your weight, height and whether you played sports, while other questions asked about whether you had a driving licence and what languages you spoke,” the 18-year-old said. He answered only the mandatory questions, which took around fifteen minutes. He knows that skipping the optional ones can increase his chances of being called in for a check-up, but he did not want to answer them all.

“The military questionnaire had many personal questions, and I found the experience quite scary, and it made me angry,” he said. “As I filled out the form, I realised how serious the government is about taking these steps to reintroduce compulsory military service.”

He is still figuring out what to study, he added, but is interested in the medical sector. “I want to help people, not shoot or harm anyone. I don’t want my future to be interrupted by the military.”

The numbers behind the letters

Official figures cited by Al Jazeera show that by the end of October, nearly 600,000 letters had been sent to young Germans this year. About 286,800 went to young men and 271,700 to women and people of other genders. The form is mandatory only for men to complete.

The rules come from the Military Service Modernisation Act, which came into effect on January 1. It sets out new targets to grow the army by the mid-2030s, increasing its full-time force to about 260,000, plus 200,000 reservists. The recruitment drive is one part of Germany’s broader military expansion, begun in 2022 after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, which also includes bigger defense budgets and more surveillance powers for intelligence services.

Advertisement

The government can point to results. According to the Ministry of Defence, the Bundeswehr has already exceeded the statutory force build-up range for 2026, with personnel numbers in October about 6,400 higher than the same month last year.

So, from Berlin’s perspective, the policy is working. From the perspective of some teenagers, that is exactly the problem.

Roofs and budgets

The protests are not only about service. They are also about priorities, and that is where the story gets personal.

Linus Schneider, 16, lives in Munich, the largest city in Bavaria, one of Germany’s wealthiest states. His school has had leaking roofs for three years. “Something wasn’t installed properly when the building was built a few years ago, and the city has been saying that they don’t have as much money as they did a few years ago, so they can’t fix the issue,” he said. “Sometimes we can’t have gym class at all because there are buckets of water in the sports hall.”

He hears similar stories from friends at other schools, and he links them to the bigger picture. “There are big cuts to education and healthcare, while at the same time, military spending has increased drastically.”

The draft 2027 federal budget, to be agreed later this month, gives his argument some numbers. Defense spending is expected to rise to 109.7 billion euros ($120.5 billion), up from 82.7 billion euros the year before. The Ministry for Education and Family projects a budget of 15.9 billion euros ($17.5 billion), compared with 16.6 billion euros this year.

It is worth being fair here. Those two figures do not tell the whole story of Germany’s finances, and defense spending has its own defenders who point to the security threats facing Europe. But for a sixteen-year-old standing in a gym with buckets on the floor, the contrast is easy to understand.

A movement with many parts

The protests are being organized by several groups. One is a loose alliance called “Gen Z Regelt” (Gen Z Sorts It), which has already staged a large demonstration. It is rallying again on Friday, with nearly 20,000 people across 40 cities, including Berlin, Cologne, Frankfurt and Munich, signed up so far. Thousands of students will also protest compulsory military service as part of a youth-led alliance called School Strike Against Conscription.

Sebastian Koos, a sociologist at the University of Konstanz who studies youth and protest movements, told Al Jazeera that a wave of similar protest across Europe was an “important spark” for the German movement. He sees overlaps, such as cost of living and cuts to education, but says conscription makes the German case unique.

Koos also pointed to a common thread of hopelessness. Participants are worried about economic and social inequality, right-wing extremism, the cost of living and climate change. “This is a lot to digest,” he said, “and it is very difficult to get a sense of hope if you are confronted with so many different conflicts.”

That sentence may be the most human in the whole story. Young people are being asked to think about war, housing, jobs and the planet all at once, usually before they have finished school.

Standing up has a price

Taking part is not always easy. Schneider told Al Jazeera that he is in trouble with his head teacher for getting involved but still plans to join Friday’s rallies. “We want to make our own decisions about our future,” he said. “We don’t want our future to be decided by the military or the state.”

He added that he thinks it is crucial to stand together “in the face of these increasing state repression that [Chancellor] Friedrich Merz is overseeing.” That is his view, and the government would no doubt describe its policies differently. But it captures how strongly some young people feel.

The other side of the argument

A fair account also has to leave room for those who support the policy. Germany’s armed forces have been under pressure for years, and the argument for a bigger, better-staffed Bundeswehr is rooted in the war in Ukraine and concerns about Russia. Supporters would say that a country cannot rely on others for its defense, and that a strong military is a form of insurance.

The government’s own figures, with personnel up by about 6,400 compared with October last year, suggest the recruitment drive is delivering. The registration form is mandatory only for men, and the law is designed, according to its own framing, to grow the force rather than simply to compel people to serve.

The dispute is therefore not simply good against bad. It is a debate about how a democracy balances security, freedom and the future of the people who will be asked to carry the burden.

What to watch

How large Friday’s rallies turn out to be, compared with the roughly 20,000 who have signed up so far.

What the final 2027 budget looks like when it is agreed later this month.

Whether the government changes how the registration process works, or the fines attached to it.

And whether the protests, which began as school-gate grumbling, turn into a lasting political force.

A last thought

Every generation argues with the one before it about war and peace. What is different today is the sense that the stakes are close at hand, with a war on Europe’s doorstep and a letter in your mailbox. Whatever one thinks of the policy, the young people marching on Friday are doing something democracy asks of its citizens: they are paying attention, and they are speaking up.